1.5 Fund design
In superannuation funds, there are two different fund designs which determine how members’ benefits are calculated:
- accumulation funds (also known as defined contribution)
- defined benefit funds (DBF).
1.5.1 Accumulation funds
An accumulation fund operates rather like a bank account. Contributions are paid into the fund and these earn income paid from the investment earnings of the fund. The contributions and investment earnings, with the administration charges, tax and other costs taken out, accumulate in the fund until the member leaves, dies or becomes permanently incapacitated.
In an accumulation fund, superannuation contributions and investment earnings are paid into the member’s account. There is no guarantee of how much money they will have in their accounts at retirement, because the member bears the risk of investment returns being negative.
The level of benefits available when a member leaves the fund depends on the level of contributions and earnings allocated to the member’s account less costs (if any) and tax deducted.
The level of benefits available when a member leaves the fund depends on the level of contributions and earnings allocated to the member’s account less costs (if any) and tax deducted.
NASFund, Nambawan Fund and Aon are all examples of accumulation funds.
NOTE: Note: These funds allocate investment returns via an annual crediting rate which is decided by the fund’s Board of Trustees |
1.5.2 Defined benefit funds
In a defined benefit fund (DBF), the superannuation contributions are paid into the fund and pooled. They are not allocated to individual members. The benefit payments are calculated using a formula that is set out in the fund’s trust deed. The formula incorporates:
- salary
- Rank
- years of service (or fund membership)
- age.
- The money in a defined benefit fund is normally kept as a single pool as member’s benefits are determined by a formula rather than reflecting what the employer actually contributes (except when less than 8yrs of service). In this type of fund, the employer bears the investment risk as the investment returns will define how much the employer must contribute to keep the pool funded. This is determined by the evaluation from an Actuarial firm.
CTSL operates as a defined benefit pension fund. Members are usually eligible for a pension after 20 years of continuous service with the Defence Force.
The amount of pension is determined through a formula which takes into account a member’s level of salary, rank, years of service and age at retirement. The pension may be payable to the member’s beneficiaries if the member dies.
The fund is funded by member contributions of 6% of their gross salary, investment returns, and a guarantee from the government to top benefits up to pay 60% of pension benefits when they fall due.
If Samson enters CTSL at age 25 and retires at age 55, he will have 30 years of membership at retirement. The fund rules state that Samson can use 100% of his super savings to purchase a pension, or take his savings out as lump sum, or a 50% combination of both. Therefore, if Samson decided to use all his savings for his pension, his retirement benefit would be: Salary × Pension Factor % (based on rank) × 30 years |
You will learn more about how benefits work for CTSL in Chapter 5 - Benefits.
Accumulation fund | Defined benefit fund |
---|---|
Bank account style benefits so they are easy to understand. | formula based benefits so they can be difficult to understand and calculate. |
Benefit accrues on the basis of salary throughout working life. | Benefit is based on most recent salary and rank. |
Future benefit projections are somewhat meaningless. | Members can predict value of future benefits (in today’s kina). |
Investment returns have a direct impact on benefits payable, so the members carry the investment risk. | Investment returns have a direct impact on funding of benefits by employers, so the employer carries the investment risk. |
Employer contributions are fixed | Employer contribution obligations can vary substantially over the longer term. |
Employer contributions are fixed. | The Public Officers Superannuation Fund Act 1990 (POSF Act 1990) replaced all previous Public Service superannuation legislation and merged the Retirement Benefit Fund with the Public Officers Superannuation Fund. This Act made superannuation compulsory for all officers and employees of the Public Service without any discrimination. |
Members can see the contributions made by the employer. | Employer contributions are not allocated to individual members. |